Broiler vs Stovetop: Cooking Time Comparison
Side-by-side cooking times for 10 foods. See which method is faster for each food.
By the CookTimeGuide Editorial TeamKitchen-tested Jan 2026
Foods Compared
10
Broiler Faster
0
Stovetop Faster
7
| Food | Broiler Temp ? | Broiler Time | Stovetop Temp ? | Stovetop Time | ← Broiler fasterStovetop faster → |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cod | high | 8-12 min | medium-high | 3-5 min | 6 min faster → |
| Flank Steak | high | 5-7 min | high | 4-6 min | 1 min faster → |
| Lamb Chops | high | 4-6 min | medium-high | 3-4 min | 1 min faster → |
| Lamb Chops (Loin) | high | 4-6 min | medium-high | 3-5 min | 1 min faster → |
| New York Strip Steak | high | 4-6 min | high | 4-5 min | Same |
| Ribeye Steak | high | 4-6 min | high | 4-5 min | Same |
| Salmon Fillet | high | 6-10 min | medium-high | 4-5 min | 3 min faster → |
| Sirloin Steak | high | 4-6 min | high | 4-5 min | Same |
| Swordfish | high | 5-8 min | medium-high | 4-5 min | 2 min faster → |
| T-Bone Steak | high | 5-7 min | high | 4-6 min | 1 min faster → |
Times shown are for the default recommended temperature for each method. Actual times may vary based on cut thickness, starting temperature, and equipment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Broiler faster than Stovetop?
Stovetop is faster for 7 out of 10 foods in this comparison. Broiler is faster for 0 foods.
Should I use Broiler or Stovetop?
Both methods produce great results. Broiler and Stovetop each excel with different foods. Use the comparison table above to see which method is faster and at what temperature for your specific food.
How many foods can be cooked with both Broiler and Stovetop?
10 foods on CookTimeGuide have cooking times for both Broiler and Stovetop. See the full comparison table above.